American Goddess at the Rape of Nanking: The Courage of Minnie Vautrin

One of the things about the Nanking Massacre, or the Rape of Nanking, or the Nanjing Incident, depending on whose book you are reading, is that there were a number of Westerners who observed what happened. If all the accounts were limited to the Chinese and the Japanese, the examination of what really happened would be limited to just the two viewpoints.

That here were Westerners present, and that they left behind various writings, and that they were basically neutral at the time (except for one who was a Nazi), adds a whole other level of information to the accounts of what happened.

Minnie Vautrin was a Christian missionary who was involved in an all-girl's school in Nanking. She is known for trying to protect the girls and other Chinese women from being raped by the Japanese soldiers.

The book starts in with her own background, where she was born, grew up, what she did, etc.

In 1919, she became the acting president of the Department of Education of Ginling College, an all-girl's school. Educating women was not something the Chinese considered very important, but for the few who did, Minnie and various other missionaries tried to set up what education they could for the girls.

It is interesting that the “Rape of Nanking” was not actually the first one at all. The book notes that, in 1927, Chiang Kai-shek's army entered Nanking and attacked the foreign consulates and schools, and threatened to rape the women.

An interesting passage: “Japan's aggression in Manchuria, North China, and Inner Mongolia provoked vigorous anti-Japanese outbreaks among the Chinese...They not only boycotted Japanese goods but also threatened Japanese lives and properties. Anti-Japanese clubs and associations mushroomed nationwide. The Japanese government repeatedly demanded that the National government suppress the people's anti-Japanese activities and outlaw all anti-Japanese organizations, and the Chinese government bowed to Japan's demands.”

1. August 1, 1937: The Nationalist government orders all dependents of its officials evacuated from Nanking.
2. August 13: Japanese planes bomb Nanking.
3. August 16: The American embassy evacuates all American women and children from the city. Japanese bombing continues.
4. August 27: Japanese planes bomb government and military buildings, residential areas, schools and hospitals.
5. September 20: The American vice consul in Nanking spoke to Minnie, reading her a message from the admiral of the Japanese fleet at Shanghai saying they would attack Nanking the following day.
6. By the end of October, the officials of the city had left, along with the rich and the middle class. “Only the military personnel and the very poor remained.”

The Japanese army entered Nanking on December 13. “...no sooner had they entered the city than they began to slaughter innocent civilians and the disarmed Chinese soldiers.” They even attacked the International Safety Zone. A New YorK Times reporter sees the Japanese kill 200 Chinese within ten minutes in the city.

A Japanese officer said that some 20,000 Chinese were shot to death at just one point in the city.

The atrocities went on for months. The author believes that more than 200,000 Chinese were killed in the massacre. There were at least 20,000 rapes in the first month of the invasion alone.

The rest of the book goes into the various incidents of girls and women being taken from where they were staying and being raped. Many of them were killed after being raped. Women as young as 12 or so were raped, and ones even in their sixties and seventies were raped.

“Four months after the fall of Nanking, the Japanese military still prohibited foreigners from entering or leaving the city. The main reason was that the Japanese soldiers continuously committed crimes, and many bodies inside and outside Nanking were yet to be buried.”

The book then goes into how and why Minnie eventually left the city, and how she got down on herself horribly about not being able to do more when she was there, and then goes into how she died.

These types of eyewitness accounts are very important, as they are from behind who didn't have any kind of axe to grind. They were often from very respectable and very intelligent people, such as Minnie, and they established a good general idea of what was going on in the city at the time.

No one person saw everything, of course, but such accounts help establish beyond doubt that something very severe happened in the city, and that many innocent people were murdered, and many girls and women were raped. While there may be arguments about exactly how many were murdered and how many raped, the very fact that many were establishes the event as a horrible and totally unnecessary event.

Revisionists try to downplay what happened, but accounts such as Minnie's prove beyond doubt that something very, very serious happened in Nanking, and that what happened was direct action of Japanese troops in a city they had already conquered.



Main Index
Japan main page
Japanese-American Internment Camps index page
Japan and World War II index page