THE WITCHCRAFT DELUSION IN COLONIAL CONNECTICUT; 1647-1697;
BY JOHN M. TAYLOR; 1908
ELIZABETH GARLICK
In 1657, when Easthampton, Long Island, was within the jurisdiction of New York, becoming a few
months later a part of Connecticut, two persons came over from Gardiner's Island and settled in the colony,
Joshua Garlick and Elizabeth his wife—whilom servants of the famous engineer and colonist Lion Gardiner.
Stories of Elizabeth's practice of witchcraft and other black arts followed her, and despite her attendance at
church she fell under suspicion, and was arrested, and held by the magistrates for trial after hearing various
witnesses. Credulity offers no better illustrations than those which fell from the lips of some of the witnesses
in this case.
Tuning a psalm—A black thing—A double tongued woman—A doleful noise—Burning the herbs—The sick
child—Gardiner's ox—The dead ram—Burning the sow's tale.
Goodwife Howell, during her illness which hastened Elizabeth's arrest, tuned a psalm and screked out
several times together very grievously, and cried a witch! a witch! now are you come to torter me because I
spoke two or three words against you, and also said, she saw a black thing at the beds featte, that Garlick was
double-tongued, pinched her with pins, and stood by the bed ready to tear her in pieces. And William Russell,
in a fit of insomnia or indigestion, before daybreak,heard a very doleful noyse on ye backside of ye fire, like
ye noyse of a great stone thrown down among a heap of stones.
Goody Birdsall declared y't she was in the house of Goody Simons when Goody Bishop came into the
house with ye dockweed and between Goody Davis and Goody Simons they burned the herbs. Farther, she
said y't formerly dressing flax at Goody Davis's house, Goody Davis saith y't she had dressed her children in
clean linen at the island, and Goody Garlick came in and said, 'How pretty the child doth look,' and so soon as
she had spoken Goody Garlick said, 'the child is not well, for it groaneth,' and Goody Davis said her heart did
rise, and Goody Davis said, when she took the child from Goody Garlick, she said she saw death in the face of
it, &her child sickened presently upon it, and lay five daies and 5 nights and never opened the eyes nor dried
till it died. Also she saith as she dothe remember Goody Davis told her upon some difference between Mr.
Gardiner or some of his family, Goodman Garlick gave out some threateningse speeches, &suddenly after Mr.
Gardiner had an ox legge broke upon Ram Island. Moreover Goody Davis said that Goody Garlick was a
naughtie woman.
Goody Edwards testified:“Y't as Goody Garlick owned, she sent to her daughter for a little best milk and
she had some and presently after, her daughters milk went away as she thought and as she remembers the
child sickened about y't time Goody Hand deposed that she had heard Goody Davis say that she hoped
Goody Garlick would not come to Eastharapton, because, she said, Goody Garlick was naughty, and there had
many sad things befallen y'm at the Island, as about ye child, and ye ox, as Goody Birdsall have declared, as
also the negro child she said was taken away, as I understood by her words, in a strange manner, and also of a
ram y't was dead, and this fell out quickly one after another, and also of a sow y't was fat and lustie and died.
She said they did burn some of the sow's tale and presently Goody Garlick did come in.
The settlers held a town meeting, and wisely questioning whether they had legal authority to hold a trial in
a capital case, they appointed a committee to go unto Keniticut to carry up Goodwife Garlick yt she may be
delivered up unto the authoritie there for the trial of the cause of witchcraft which she is suspected for. The
General Court of Connecticut took jurisdiction of the case, a trial of Goody Garlick was held, resulting in her
acquittal, and she was sent back to Easthampton, to what end is not told in the records of the day.
Back to start of Spirituality section
My Index Page
|